The Ninth District Court of Appeals held that there was no requirement that the parents be unfit or unsuitable before appointing a guardian to a 10-year-old cancer patient whose parents took her off chemotherapy. The case involved an Amish family and their daughter, who had an advanced stage of Leukemia. The parents consented to their daughter receiving chemotherapy but, after seeing the treatments side effects, stopped chemotherapy and used only natural, holistic medicine. Their doctor, believing the girl would die within six months, asked the hospitals legal staff to appoint a guardian to make the girls medical decisions. The trial court denied the request. The appellate court found that the trial court had incorrectly applied a custody standard to a guardian-appointment case that should have been decided under R.C. § 2111.06. Under this statute, there are three separate, disjunctive grounds for appointment of the limited guardian over a minor: 1) the minor has no parents, 2) the minors parents are unsuitable, or 3) if the minors interest will be promoted by appointment of the guardian. The appellate court held there was no requirement to find the parents to be unfit or unsuitable before appointing a guardian under the third prong. The case was remanded to the trial court to make its determination under the statute without taking the parents suitability into account.
Recent Posts
- Shana DeMooy Appointed to Ohio State Bar Association Estate Planning, Trust, and Probate Law Section Council
- Weathering the Coming 鈥淧robate Storm鈥�
- 花都影视 Secures Favorable Probate Court Judgment in Undue Influence Dispute
- Love, Death, And Litigation: Enforcing Prenuptial Agreements Upon Death
- The Illusion of Competence: Surviving the AI Wave Through Bans, Disclosures, and Bots
- Forrest and Gallagher secure a dismissal with prejudice in trust and fiduciary litigation involving the estate of the late Eric鈥疌armen, a musician and Cleveland native
- Shana DeMooy Featured in Columbus Jewish News Local Lawyers / Super Attorneys 2026
- Jessica Forrest Elected as a Member of the American College of Trust and Estate Counsel (ACTEC)
- Michael Brody and Paul Shugar Secure Positive Result in Trust Dispute
- Strategies for Litigation-Proofing Estate Plans











